Poverty and American National Priorities
The Boisi Center convened three distinguished scholars from diverse perspectives to discuss the nature of poverty in the United States and the issue’s place (or lack thereof) among American national priorities.
On Tuesday, February 26, the Boisi Center convened three distinguished scholars from diverse perspectives to discuss the nature of poverty in the United States and the issue’s place (or lack thereof) among American national priorities.
Renowned sociologist William Julius Wilson, the Lewis P. and Linda L. Geyser University Professor at Harvard University, opened the panel with an analysis of the relationship between race, ethnicity and poverty. While affirming President Barack Obama’s call (in his 2013 State of the Union Address) for all young people to obtain a good education and solid job skills, Wilson lamented that today’s high schools frequently fail to provide these benefits to black and Latino youths. Despite the sizeable gains that racial minorities in the United States have made in education, their high school graduation rates and college matriculation rates are still low. This failure of education—combined with a climate of industry restructuring, globalization, deregulation, de-unionization, and recession—has led to a decline of unskilled, decently paying jobs in America. In response, workers have been forced to reduce hours, take lower paying jobs, or even leave the work force entirely. This trend disproportionately affects blacks and Latinos, Wilson argued.
These occupational trends are deeply connected to residential segregation based on race, ethnicity, and class. Poor neighborhoods are moreover hit especially hard in recessions because of budget cuts and the resulting decline in the quality of public services. Wilson suggested that we ought to consider comprehensive, school-based job-building initiatives to mitigate or even correct these problems.
Susan Crawford Sullivan, associate professor of sociology at the College of the Holy Cross, discussed the role of religion in the lives of the poor, especially single mothers on welfare. Many poor women employ religious narratives to interpret their suffering and see themselves as working with God to face their daily challenges. Despite high rates of religious belief, most poor women do not attend church regularly. Although churches are often seen as havens for the poor, the women in Sullivan’s study explained that they frequently felt stigmatized by and unwanted in religious communities. This disconnect between the churches and the poor is particularly troubling, Sullivan claimed, because religious communities can potentially offer much needed spiritual, emotional, and material support to poor single mothers.
Princeton University theologian Eric Gregory concluded the panel with a powerful theological reflection on American national priorities. While equality does not require economic sameness, he argued, economic inequality often serves as a proxy for political inequality. The covert financial and economic prerequisites of our political process alienate the poor and serve as an intolerable form of systematic inequality. Our institutions and public policy reflect the character of our nation; what we value and what we accept or refuse to tolerate says much about who we are as Americans. Gregory questioned both the priorities of the state and the Christian church today, pointing to unfulfilled promises of freedom and justice. Few politicians today prioritize care for the poor, he argued, and the church is not much better. “Imagine a world,” Gregory said, “where poverty was debated with only half the intensity of homosexuality in America and the Catholic Church.”
Insofar as markets are structures created by humans, they can be changed by humans. To this end, Gregory closed with a call to replenish our commitment to poverty relief by recalling the deeper history of our interconnectedness. We must break the siren call of narrowly defined economic interest, he said, by bringing the wisdom of the Church back into the public sphere.
Mary Jo Bane and Lawrence M. Mead. Lifting Up the Poor: A Dialogue on Religion, Poverty and Welfare Reform. (Brookings Institution Press, 2003).
Eric Gregory. Politics and the Order of Love: An Augustinian Ethic of Democratic Citizenship. (University of Chicago Press, 2008).
Susan Crawford Sullivan. Living Faith: Everyday Religion and Mothers in Poverty. (University of Chicago Press, 2011).
Susan Crawford Sullivan. "Unaccompanied Children in Churches: Low-Income Urban Single Mothers, Religion, and Parenting." Review of Religious Research, 50 (2): 157-175. 2008.
William Julius Wilson. The Bridge over the Racial Divide: Rising Inequality and Coalition Politics. (University of California Press, 2001).
William Julius Wilson. When Work Disappears: The World of the New Urban Poor. (Vintage Books, 1997).
William Julius Wilson. The Truly Disadvantaged:The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. (University of Chicago Press, 1987).
William Julius Wilson. The Declining Significance of Race. (University of Chicago Press, 1980).
Delbert S. Elliott, Scott Menard, Bruce Rankin, Amanda Elliott, William Julius Wilson, and David Huizinga. Good Kids from Bad Neighborhoods: Successful Development in Social Context. (Cambridge University Press, 2006).
Nazmun Ratna, Baiding Hu, and Ian MacDonald. "Economic Impact of Poverty and Social Isolation: an Exploration with US State Data". Eurasia Business and Economics Society, November 2012.
Brandon Vick, Kristine Jones, and Sophie Mitra. "Poverty and Psychiatric Diagnosis in the U.S.: Evidence from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey". Fordham University Department of Economics, November 2010.
Max Rose and Frank R. Baumgartner. "Framing the Poor: Media Coverage and US Poverty Policy, 1960-2008". Policy Studies Journal, 2012.
Jina Moore. "Below the line: Poverty in America". Christian Science Monitor, October 7, 2012.
See how much money people make in every neighborhood in every city in America with Rich Blooks, Poor Blocks
View the website for the Pew Economic Mobility Project.
U.S. Census Bureau. "Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2011".
In the News
Nicholas Kristof, in a New York Times op-ed, encourages President Obama to make poverty a policy priority during his second term.
Thomas Edsall's New York Times opinion piece about the hidden prosperity of the poor traces the debate over the consumption theory, which suggests that even as income inequality worsens, the disparity between the amount of money spent on goods and services by the rich, the middle class and the poor remains relatively stable.