Immigration is often framed in terms of crisis management, rather than by analyzing the economic and political realities that caused it. By scapegoating or focusing on enforcement responses, these underlying and enduring problems are ignored. In the US context in particular, political rhetoric masks complicity, abets human rights violations and betrays the nation’s founding principles. The lenses that shape the immigration debate in the US can distort the realities that migrants face and become surrogates for other cultural and political concerns. Focusing solely on economic or fear-based approaches too often dehumanizes newcomers. In her talk at the Boisi Center, Heyer will explore contributions that Scripture and the Catholic social tradition offer the immigration dialogue. These resources challenge the dominant, instrumentalist frameworks and offer a counter-narrative of civic kinship.
On April 5 Kristin Heyer, professor of theology at Boston College, spoke at a Boisi Center luncheon about the state of immigration in the United States. Many responses to immigration in the U.S. fail to account for the structural causes of migration and serve to dehumanize migrants. Despite the United States’ long history of immigration, the current operative lenses dominating discourse on migration present immigrants as a threat to national security, as a drain on the economy, and as disruptive to social cohesion and national identity. Heyer also argued that perceiving immigrants as threats to social cohesion or national identity often takes the dangerous form of xenophobia or Islamophobia.
According to Heyer, a Christian ethics of migration could offer an alternative to these dehumanizing lenses. By recognizing immigrants as persons with individual dignity, it exhorts justice for immigrants, not merely pity. Additionally, it addresses the root causes of immigration and our complicity in these causes. Profiting off of immigrants’ desperation runs counter to the Scriptural command to care for the stranger. Only by identifying the root causes of immigration, Heyer maintained, can we correct our views of immigration and work toward restorative justice.
Viewing immigrants as national security threats arose out of the pervasive post-9/11 concern with terrorism. Also, since ISIS has been able to infiltrate and conduct terrorist attacks in Europe through existing migrant channels for Syrian refugees, the American public has grown wary of accepting immigrants from the Middle East.
Immigrants are often put into categories of ‘takers’ or ‘makers’ with respect to the economy. The work of many economists who say that immigrants can be a boon to the economy, because they pay taxes but receive few benefits, refutes this language. In fact, the for-profit detention industry in the U.S. reaps billions of dollars each year, thus creating a perverse economic incentive to detain and deport more and more people.
Benhabib, Seyla and Judith Resnik, eds. Migration and Mobilities: Citizenship, Borders and Gender. (New York University Press, 2009).
Brazal, Agnes and M. T. Davila, eds. Catholic Theological Ethics on the Migrations of Peoples: Living with(out) Borders. (Orbis Books, 2015).
Groody, Daniel G. and Giachinno Campese, eds. A Promised Land, A Perilous Journey: Theological Perspectives on Migration. (Notre Dame Press, 2008).
Carens, Joseph H. The Ethics of Immigration. (Oxford University Press, 2013).
Heyer, Kristin. Kinship Across Borders: A Christian Ethic of Immigration. (Georgetown University Press, Moral Traditions series, 2012).
Hing, Bill Ong. Deporting our Souls: Values, Morality and Immigration Policy. (Cambridge University Press, 2006).
Hollenbach, David, SJ, ed. Driven from Home: Protecting the Rights of Forced Migrants. (Georgetown University Press, 2010).
Hollenbach, David, SJ, ed. Refugee Rights: Ethics Advocacy, and Africa. (Georgetown University Press, 2008).
Ngai, Mae M. Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. (Princeton University Press, 2004).
James Carroll's article in The New Yorker, "The Radical Meaning of Pope Francis's Visit to Juárez."
Daniel Groody's article in America, "Deporting the Heart."
David Hollenbach's, SJ, article in America, "The Rights of Refugees."
Kristin Heyer's article in Asian Horizons, “The Politics of Immigration and a Catholic Counternarrative: A Perspective from the United States."
Kristin Heyer's articles in Theological Studies, “Reframing Displacement and Membership: Ethics of Migration" and “Social Sin and Immigration: Good Fences make Bad Neighbors."
Kristin Heyer's article in Health Care Ethics USA, “A Christian Ethic of Immigration."
William O’Neill's, SJ, article in The Journal of the Society of Christian Ethics, “Rights of Passage: Ethics of Forced Displacement.”
In the News
Neatly divided along ideological lines, Democratic presidential candidates have pledged support for a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants, while the leading Republican candidates have opposed any such path and instead favored an increase in border security and deportation. In her upcoming talk at the Boisi Center Kristin Heyer will address how securitization and scapegoating in the United States' immigration debate detracts from addressing the structural economic and political realities that underlie immigration to this country.