Journal Contents

Student Publications Homepage

ARTICLE CONTENTS

[Pages 1-36]
TOP OF ARTICLE

Introduction
I.  Eisentrager
II.  Rasul v. Bush
    A.  The Ruling
    B.  Its Reach
III.  Line Drawing for a New Kind of Conflict
    A.  Justice Jackson as a Starting Point
    B.  Analyzing the Functional Impact of Judicial Review of Military Detention
    C.  The Importance of Hamdi
    D.  The Current Process at Guantanamo
    E.  Implications for Establishing the Right Balance—
The Military Side of the Scale

        1.  Military Officers as Primary Decisionmakers
        2.  The Limited Role for Courts in Factfinding, Once the Military Tribunal Has Matured
        3.  Judge Wilkinson’s Further Line-Drawing Challenge
        F.  The Other Side of the Scale—The Protection of Rights
        1.  The Court’s Role in Each Domain
        2.  Real-World Effects on the Administration of Even a Deferential Standard of Review
              a.  Initial Responses
              b.  Illustrations
              c.  The Paradox
Conclusion: Acoustic Separation That Helps Achieve the Needed Balance